For Their Own Sake, Single Player Studios Need to Stop Chasing the Live Service Trend

For Their Own Sake, Single Player Studios Need to Stop Chasing the Live Service Trend

Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League has been on the receiving finish of what has appeared like overwhelming criticism following its launch. Although the open world looter shooter has acquired some reserved reward for issues like its visuals and the standard of its cutscenes, almost each different essential a part of the expertise has been criticized, from the open world to the repetitive mission design, from the paper-thin stay service choices to the poorly applied loot mechanics, from a number of the narrative choices it makes to the actual fact that it’s designed as a stay service expertise.

That final one, in truth, has been a very robust sentiment- and it’s not an unfamiliar one by any means. Greater than something, greater than the entire points that the sport has launched with, the factor about Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League that has been most upsetting to numerous gamers is the truth that this is a Rocksteady sport. With the Batman: Arkham trilogy, Rocksteady Studios delivered three stellar, excellently-designed, completely authored single participant experiences, setting new requirements for superhero video games and licensed video games that almost all nonetheless fail to fulfill to this present day.

To see Rocksteady itself falling so woefully low of the requirements it set itself has been stunning. The developer says it plans on releasing important content material updates for loads of time to return, with a yr 1 roadmap having already been laid out. Whether or not or not that can have any significant influence on the sport, its high quality, and the way it’s performing stays to be seen- for now, all indicators level to no. And it’s honest to say that the overwhelming bulk of the blame for this failure lies with the plain and easy proven fact that Suicide Squad is designed, at the beginning, as an ongoing multiplayer expertise that may function as a persistent income stream for Warner Bros. And actually, Rocksteady is way from the primary once-excellent single player-focused studio to fall sufferer to that mentality. Quite a lot of such studios have tried to chase the stay service pattern, and with nearly no exceptions, just about none of them have succeeded in any significant method.

In 2020, as an example, when it was nonetheless below Sq. Enix’s possession, Crystal Dynamics got here out with Marvel’s Avengers. After having made its title as a studio recognized for crafting glorious, linear, story-driven single participant experiences, below instructions from its guardian firm, the studio determined to take a large superhero property that may have been ripe for a promising single participant expertise, and as an alternative determined to show it right into a stay service loot-driven sport. The similarities between the Avengers and Suicide Squad conditions are nearly uncanny, truthfully, and it went about in addition to most of us had anticipated.

Marvel’s Avengers bombed in almost each method potential. It was a bland, repetitive expertise that supplied little to no motive for gamers to wish to maintain enjoying it over a chronic time frame. Aside from an honest marketing campaign, the sport had only a few redeeming qualities, which, unsurprisingly, led to widespread backlash and lukewarm reception (some would argue even that’s a charitable description), which in flip was mirrored in poor gross sales and persistently low participant engagement numbers. Marvel’s Avengers died a fast demise a bit of over two years after launch, and when that occurred, nobody was stunned. When Crystal Dynamics confirmed later that with its subsequent venture, a brand new Tomb Raider sport, it was going to return to creating a story-driven single participant expertise, as soon as once more, nobody was surprised- however we have been all massively revealed, to say the very least.

Earlier than that, we had BioWare, one other beloved studio recognized for its genre-defining single participant video games that determined to chase the stay service looter shooter pattern by delivering what might very properly be one of many worst stay service looter shooters ever made (a doubtful crown that there’s a stunning quantity of competitors for, with Suicide Squad being the latest – and maybe probably the most outstanding – contender). Completely nothing about Anthem worked- not solely did it fail at being a superb BioWare sport, it additionally failed on the issues that it was making an attempt to be. With subsequent to no redeeming qualities (except its flying mechanics, perhaps), Anthem additionally died an unsurprisingly fast demise.

Even when BioWare insisted for a stretch that it was engaged on a significant overhaul of the sport dubbed Anthem Subsequent, there was little to no confidence wherever that that may ever really materialize, or if it did, that it could reverse the sport’s fortunes in any significant method. In fact, these plans ended up getting shelved, and BioWare has now very concretely pivoted again to being a single player-only studio, to the purpose the place not solely each of its main upcoming video games are solo experiences, however it has additionally fully handed off all future growth of its long-running MMORPG, Star Wars: The Outdated Republic, to an exterior studio. If solely somebody had informed BioWare that chasing the stay service pattern would result in nothing good, proper? They’d have saved themselves the last decade that they ended up losing on and round Anthem.

One other latest instance is Redfall. With the likes of Dishonored and Prey below its belt, Arkane Studios established itself as most likely one of the best developer of immersive sims within the {industry}, so to see a sport as shockingly unhealthy as Redfall from a studio with that form of pedigree was, to place it mildly, a little bit of a shock. Very similar to Anthem, not solely was Redfall not good at being the form of expertise that its developer had constructed its repute on, it additionally did not be good on the new factor that it was making an attempt to be- and spectacularly so. Because it got here out, there was some discuss that Arkane intends to stay it out and proceed supporting the sport, however almost a yr on from the sport’s launch, that has amounted to a complete lot of nothing. Because it stands, it’s trying like Redfall isn’t going to make any form of a restoration.


Actually, it’s been a soul-crushing sample within the {industry} these previous couple of years, the place industry-leading studios recognized for his or her painstakingly hand-crafted single participant experiences find yourself becoming a member of the sickening stay service gold rush. Invariably, the top end result finally ends up being a soulless sport designed round cookie cutter, repetitive, boring content material, all of which fails to seize something that the studios as soon as was so broadly beloved for. And to be clear, that’s not as a result of it’s inherently not possible to make a superb stay service game- from Future to Fortnite to The Division, we’ve had loads of examples of video games which have managed to get it proper (properly, for probably the most half). However you recognize what the largest distinction is with these video games? They have been developed by studios that have been consultants at delivering and sustaining ongoing multiplayer experiences, not by studios who immediately needed to do a 180-pivot and develop one thing they have been fully unfamiliar with, all within the hopes of creating extra money.

Have there been any exceptions? Shockingly few, and truthfully, none with out caveats. Uncommon has managed to profitable to transition from being a single participant developer to a stay service studio with Sea of Thieves, however as nice as that sport is now, it needed to undergo some critical rising pains for some time after launch. Perhaps you might depend Fallout 76? It’s definitely in a significantly better state now than it as soon as was, it receives constant help and content material additions, and it has a reasonably sizeable and engaged playerbase- however all of us keep in mind absolutely the catastrophe that was its launch, and even in its present state, the sport has its justifiable share of points.

Studios desirous to experiment and check out new issues ought to by no means be discouraged, of course- if not for studios desirous to strive new issues, the likes of BioWare, Arkane, Rocksteady, and Crystal Dynamics wouldn’t have turn into the juggernauts they’re within the first place. However at this level, it’s turn into painfully clear (it has been for some time, in truth) that this stay service push doesn’t come from a spot of desirous to be creatively experimental. These pivots are pushed at the beginning by monetary reasons- which isn’t stunning. These are all profit-driven companies, in any case. However in chasing that pot of gold, these studios find yourself shedding the whole lot that they did that acquired them to their lofty perches within the {industry}, whereas additionally failing to select up the brand new abilities they should ship the kind of expertise they’re now seeking to make. Nearly each single time, in such a state of affairs, there are by no means any winners.


Will the {industry} be taught? We will solely hope. Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League is one other in a protracted checklist of outstanding cautionary tales, however thus far, builders and publishers haven’t taken be aware. We will solely hope that this proves to be the straw that broke the camel’s again.

Observe: The views expressed on this article are these of the writer and don’t essentially characterize the views of, and shouldn’t be attributed to, GamingBolt as a company.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.