The Harry Potter Books Definitively Proved That Voldemort Was Worse Than Grindelwald

The Harry Potter Books Definitively Proved That Voldemort Was Worse Than Grindelwald


  • Grindelwald’s ultimate moments revealed his capability for regret and redemption, one thing Voldemort lacked utterly.
  • Regret performed a big function within the Harry Potter sequence, serving as an important step in the direction of redemption and the flexibility to like.
  • Grindelwald’s willingness to die to guard Dumbledore’s secret and forestall Voldemort’s mission showcased his heroic actions, contrasting sharply with Voldemort’s lack of disgrace or guilt.

The controversy about whether or not Voldemort or Grindelwald was the more serious villain has raged for years, however the Harry Potter books have the definitive reply. Voldemort was the massive dangerous of the unique sequence, with Grindelwald serving because the villain of the prequel Improbable Beasts motion pictures. Every had an analogous trigger—to lift wizarding variety above that of the (believed) inferior Muggles. Nonetheless, Voldemort and Grindelwald had various strategies and ended their Harry Potter tales drastically totally different from each other, revealing which ones had been worse.

Gellert Grindelwald rose to energy in Europe across the Thirties utilizing his mantra of “for the larger good.” As was seen in Improbable Beasts, he preached that wizarding rule was good for Muggles, an concept that had been introduced by a younger Albus Dumbledore a few years beforehand. In fact, he took this a number of steps too far and murdered numerous Muggles and political enemies as his motion grew. Dumbledore ultimately defeated him and positioned him in jail (Nurmengard). This was the place he lived out the remainder of his days and the place, in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, he proved that he wasn’t as irredeemable as Lord Voldemort.

RELATED: Harry Potter Ought to Have Develop into A Villain (& Dumbledore Knew It)

Grindelwald Expressed Regret Earlier than His Loss of life In Harry Potter

The Harry Potter motion pictures confirmed the second of Gellert Grindelwald’s demise by the hands of Voldemort, however they unnoticed the numerous particulars about his ultimate moments. Within the books, the Darkish Lord had come to Nurmengard figuring out that Grindelwald had as soon as had the Elder Wand. When he requested his villain predecessor what had occurred to the weapon, Grindelwald claimed that he had by no means had it and refused to disclose the reality even as soon as Voldemort had raised his wish to kill him. He died defending Dumbledore’s secret, one thing Harry identified to Dumbledore in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows:

“‘Grindelwald tried to cease Voldemort going after the wand. He lied, , pretended he had by no means had it.’

Dumbledore nodded, wanting down at his lap, tears nonetheless glittering on the crooked nostril.

‘They are saying he confirmed regret in later years, alone in his cell at Nurmengard. I hope that it’s true. I want to assume he did really feel the horror and disgrace of what he had finished. Maybe that misinform Voldemort was his try to make amends … to stop Voldemort from taking the Hallow …’

‘… or possibly from breaking into your tomb?’ steered Harry, and Dumbledore dabbed his eyes.” – Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows

It is unclear the place Dumbledore heard that Grindelwald had expressed regret for the injury he had finished throughout the motion seen in Improbable Beasts, however it may be assumed that it was good info. As Harry steered, Grindelwald hadn’t wished Voldemort to desecrate Dumbledore’s grave to retrieve the Elder Wand and was keen to die to ensure that Voldemort’s mission—one which had as soon as aligned along with his personal targets—would not have assistance from the Hallow. The villain definitely deserved his imprisonment and even perhaps his demise. Nonetheless, he died a kind of hero, one thing that would by no means be mentioned of Voldemort.

Voldemort’s Loss of life Proved He Couldn’t Really feel Regret (& Was The Worse Villain)

Voldemort's Death in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part II

Grindelwald was fortunate sufficient to show his regret within the ultimate moments of his life, and he took full benefit by doing all he may to maintain Voldemort from getting his fingers on the Elder Wand. Although the Harry Potter motion pictures skipped it over, Voldemort was given an analogous likelihood within the books. Throughout their ultimate battle, Harry challenged Voldemort to really feel regret, telling him it was his solely likelihood to avoid wasting his soul.

Because the Darkish Lord had dedicated homicide to separate his soul into items (and thus created his Horcruxes), he couldn’t go onto the afterlife, which made his demise in Harry Potter much more satisfying. An entire and full soul can go on, however a fragmented one can be misplaced perpetually. Hermione revealed in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows that the one strategy to reform a soul was to expertise regret. Harry informed Voldemort this, however the Darkish Lord was each uninterested and incapable. Not like Grindelwald, he felt no disgrace or guilt for his atrocious actions.

Why Regret Was So Necessary In The Harry Potter Collection

Fantastic Beasts secrets of dumbledore detail links grindelwald to Voldemort

The thought of regret is a typical theme all through Harry Potter. It would not clear an individual of their crimes, but it surely was a necessary step towards redemption—the concept if an individual had a deep and thorough remorse for his or her dangerous actions, it could create a foothold for like to safe itself to the soul. This was seen in Severus Snape, who behaved horribly from begging to finish of the Harry Potter sequence, however the regret he felt for his half in Lily’s demise allowed him to nonetheless positively affect Harry’s final battle with Lord Voldemort.

The truth that Grindelwald skilled regret like this did not change the truth that he was a strong and horrible villain, but it surely revealed a capability to like that would not exist in somebody actually previous saving. Voldemort had no such capability. He had dedicated probably the most atrocious of murders in an effort to sever his soul, a step that Grindelwald hadn’t dared to take. Ultimately, there isn’t any competitors. Voldemort was previous saving in Harry Potter as a result of he could not expertise regret, whereas Grindelwald, the definitive lesser of two evils, discovered peace and redemption in his ultimate moments.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.